December 14, 2008

Håvard Skjæveland and the Problem of Evil

I am currently engaged in an email discussion with a young Norwegian by the name of Håvard Skjæveland on the Problem of Evil argument against the existence of God. (His internet footprint is outdated, he tells me, so take whatever you find about him with a grain of salt.) Our discussion began about four days ago and is still ongoing. Once it is completed, I intend to publish the results here in my blog, having received his permission to do so. Keep an eye out for this. He is a very intelligent, articulate, and respectful young man and our discussion is proving to be quite fruitful, certainly on my end.

(NOTE: As it stands right now, the discussion is shifting away from the problem of ‘evil’ in favour of the problem of ‘suffering’, but I am leaving the title as it is because whether the issue is ‘evil’ or ‘suffering’ the fundamental context is synonymous.)

December 3, 2008

Knowing a Personal God

When it comes to understanding the concept of God as a "personal God," who loves me, cares for me, and desires to have a relationship with me, I just don't get it. It doesn't make sense to me; I feel awkward when I pray, and just don't understand how, out of 6 billion people, I matter a hill of beans to the guy who created the universe. Surely, having done that, he has much more important concerns than lowly I . . . Logically, I can convince myself that God exists, but it doesn't go much beyond that. So, that's where I'm stuck, and have been stuck, for the past number of years.

He did more than create this vast and complex universe. The reason why out of some six billion people you, as a unique person, matter to God can be very succinctly stated: he also created you. Given what you have said elsewhere in this thread, I have a hunch that your view of God has more in common with Deism than with Christianity; e.g., "I view God as some abstract figure somewhere far off in the distance." It is inherently difficult to develop or even recognize a relationship with a God who created the entire cosmos and then stepped back while the universe developed under its own impetus. There is no point of contact with such a God; it feels like several billion years of evolution separates you from the last time God had anything to do with his creation. Ergo, he makes sense analytically but not on the personal level at which you exist.

That's a significant obstacle. So I suggest that the first step you need to take in order to bridge this awkward chasm is to evaluate your view of God. Currently your view of God, being more similar to Deism than anything, makes it practically impossible to develop a relationship with God. So sit back and ask yourself, "How is it I came to have this view of God? What informed my view? Is it accurate?" The only reason we know that God is more than some transcendent abstract entity—the only reason we know anything about God at all—is because he disclosed information about himself to mankind. Let me flesh out this concept allegorically.

A friend of Morgan's told her that there exists some writer named David, and had sufficient evidence for that claim enough for Morgan to accept it analytically. However, on the personal level it was practically meaningless to her. She had no idea who David is, other than what was provided by the proposition about his existence and that he is a writer. She may contemplate about him, trying to infer what she can from the fact that he is a writer, but in the final analysis he is a proposition, not a person. Yet what if she came across a number of books he had written not only about himself, describing his character and values, but also about things he had said to this person and done at that place, etc.? It stands to reason that David would then mean something more to her than he did before, because now she knows so much more about him as a person. There is still no personal connection between them, but he has certainly assumed enough new dimensions that she can see him as a person. (Real world example: at one point Barack Obama was nothing more meaningful to me than a name, until I read his autobiography. There is no personal connection between he and I, but for me he is now more than just a name; he is a person.) But now imagine that in one of the letters she discovered that David is her father, that she belongs to him. It stands to reason that he would then mean a great deal more to her than he ever did. By exploring what David had revealed about himself, for Morgan he went from being an empty proposition to a meaningful person—with whom she could have a relationship, and to whom she meant a lot.

Now maybe this allegory is too simplistic, perhaps it has some weakness in its relationship to the point I am trying to make here, but just keep in mind that it's being recommended more for its illustrative power than its accuracy. You believe that God created the universe, and that's certainly accurate. However, he did more than just create the universe. He also created you, which is one good reason why you matter "a hill of beans" to this Almighty Creator. You are not some inconsequential accident of nature that barely registers in significance on the scale of the vast cosmos. You are a significant creation of God himself, someone whose significance is such that God went to inexpressible ends in order to claim you through adoption into his family. And I say these things because I am deeply familiar with and convinced by the information God has disclosed about himself to mankind, which is both how and why God is for me more than an analytic proposition. For me, Obama went from being an empty name to a real person because I spent time learning about him from the things he revealed about himself. God went from being a proposition to a significant person the same way; but he came to mean so much more when I discovered that not only do I belong to him but also that he went to profound ends to adopt me as a child into his family.

So that is my encouragement to you. The more time you spend exploring and genuinely meditating upon the things God has revealed about himself, his character and actions, and how it relates to you as his own purposeful creation, the easier it will become to have that relationship with him which has thus far eluded you. It will often feel more like a 'long distance relationship' than a daily person-to-person relationship but God also explains why things are (for now) this way, with the promise that the day is coming when the distance that sin has wedged between us and God will be done away with, once this final battle has been fought and decisively concluded, and we will once again enjoy the Edenic paradise we are ultimately intended for.

Going to church is downright depressing. Walking into church with 1,000 people who do "get it" makes me feel inferior (they get it but I don't), defective, and just plain old dumb. What do they know that I don't? is what I'm thinking . . . My faith, such as it is, is always weaker leaving church than it is when I go.

I also want to point out that a relationship with God is not characterized only by euphoric praising and such. I see that too, in church, with people raising their arms in joyful expressions of awe as they worship. But that is only part of the picture. After church there is the rest of Sunday afternoon and the journey from Monday all the way to Saturday filled with the mundane pressures of this life we live. And you know this, I'm sure. I could be one of those people at your church who looks like they "get it" to you, but you have no idea what I am dealing with in my life or what my Tuesday evening looks like. I guarantee you that there are times where you would look at me and think, "Maybe he doesn't get it either, like me." (Perhaps even more so because, like you, I am rather stoic in the emotional arena. I do feel, but I don't wear it on my sleeve. I exercise a degree of control over my emotions that could be characterized as Vulcan, amplified by my love for logic.)

And by the way? I am also confident enough to guarantee you that most of those 1,000 people are indeed faking it (i.e., their behavior in church is diametrically inconsistent with their behavior otherwise). It might be politically incorrect to say such things about church people but I've never had much respect for political correctness. In my life, candid honesty takes priority. They won't admit it because there is such a sensitivity for the integrity of faith, but many of those people are indistinguishable from unbelievers the rest of the week—unfamiliar with Scripture, do not know anything about God, can’t explain salvation, etc. I think it's a good thing that you have within you this longing to feel a connection with God, but don't allow yourself to think that they "get it" while you don't. Some of them are in the same boat you're in, and others "get it" even less than you do. Don't feel inferior, defective, or dumb. There is no need to feel weaker leaving the service. I encourage you to pursue this longing you have, but never compare yourself to others because you have no idea if their behavior at church is a product of faith or just a social performance.

And finally, a relationship with God is not based "soley on emotions and love." A relationship with God is based on a commitment to him. The emotional feeling of love for God comes with time as you get to know him, which is a product of your sanctification, a process that never ends on this side of the resurrection. There were several years between my commitment to God and my love for him. My love for God, and how much I love him, was a work in progress. I did not exit my conversion with love for God. Reverence? Humility? Respect? Yes. But love only came after I got to know him, which took years of spending time genuinely exploring the gospel of his Son Jesus Christ and the ministry of his apostles, sometimes on my own but mostly through the help of others far more mature than I in their knowledge of God and relationship to him.

If Jesus is God, then Jesus should get as much "airtime" as God does . . . If Jesus is mentioned once, God is mentioned 100 times. If they are essentially one and the same, why aren't they referred to equally? This is a tangent, but something that's been troubling me so.

If Jesus is God, then he was being mentioned 101 times.

It is so easy to think of 'God' as being a name and a person distinct from Jesus. It's not. When we are talking about God, that doesn't mean we are failing to talk about Jesus. 'God' is who he is, and 'Jesus' is his name (or the English version of the Greek Iesous).

November 16, 2008

On Becoming a Christian

This is from an old email but I thought I would turn it into a blog post because I think it conveys some important points for consideration, to meditate upon. The question was asked:

What does it feel like to be Christian? Did you just know you were saved, like—bam—"Hey, I'm saved now" or what?

I'll be frank with you: there is no simple one-size-fits-all answer to this question. That will become strikingly evident as you notice the degree to which responses will vary. And with a thing as deep and rich and complex as the Christian faith, which at its core is a living relationship with God through Christ Jesus, that should be expected.

I shall tell you what I think this question is like. Take three women: one who has been newly married for one year, one who has been married for five years, and one who has been married for twenty years. Sit them all down in front of you and ask each of them to tell you what it feels like to be married. Are you going to get one basic, simple answer that will be consistent from all the women?

Would you even expect it? I should think not, and in that sort of context it is easy to see why. But the fact of the matter is, that is exactly what being a Christian is like. It is a relationship, a very loving, very deep, very committed relationship, one which the apostle Paul finds appropriately analogous to marriage—but a marriage in the deeply religious sense, not in the just-a-piece-of-paper sense it has been reduced to.

A woman who has only been married for one year will describe the experience quite differently from the woman who has been married for twenty years, just as a new Christian will describe their experience in terms rather different from someone who has been a Christian for decades. As relationships mature and deepen, new experiences and values are discovered and enjoyed, problems arise and get worked out and so forth. Someone who became a Christian last year will not have yet experienced the dynamic trials and triumphs of someone who has had a relationship with God for the last twenty years. For that matter, the trials and triumphs of each will not even be the same when they do happen, since every relationship is unique.

There is no simple, easily packaged and slogan-ready answer that can be offered to this question, quite honestly. This must be understood, not just by you but any honest inquirer. Christianity is not simply a set of metaphysical propositions to which one gives intellectual assent and somehow, like some altered state of consciousness, one magically feels a little differently. Propositions simply do not have that property.

Relationships do. And at the very core of Christianity is God, a personal being with whom one enters into a relationship through the incarnate Son of God, Jesus Christ, about whom both the Scriptures and the corporate body of believers attest. Myself, I have been a Christian for about ten years now, in a very complex, fluid, and dynamic relationship with God on both the intellectual and emotional level. (God has a funny tendency to grab your whole entire being.) I began this journey as an atheist and—as if that did not already change my entire world—later experienced two more paradigm-shattering changes at the most fundamental levels of my epistemic convictions. Anything I could say about what being a Christian is like is going to reflect that unique personal history and those levels of enlightenment, insight, and profound growth in the knowledge and wisdom of Christ. An answer from someone else will reflect a dramatically different sort of history, and will vary to an even larger degree if that person has had a shorter or longer relationship with God.

What does it feel like to be a Christian? It feels like meeting, falling in love with, and marrying the most wonderful person in the whole world, and that experience intensifies and deepens and becomes more complex and intricate the longer you are married, a marriage whose dimensions and contours are shaped by a history rich with experiences of love, anger, relief, sadness, joy, betrayal, repentance, elation, and so on.

But that whole meeting the person for the first time? For a lot of people it can be a little awkward. It was for me too, including when that person is God.

November 14, 2008

Obama Hatred

"Disgusting," a friend commented on my Facebook profile when the social networking web site publicized my becoming a Barack Obama supporter. I stared at that word for several minutes, dumbfounded. I could not decide how to feel or how to react. I felt a number of conflicting feelings simultaneously, mostly because that person had been my best friend for the last four years and typically had respect for my decisions. I placed my fingers over the keyboard, paused, then pulled them back. I stared at that word again. "Disgusting." It bewildered me. I did not know what to make of it. I went to type a response again, but once again my fingers hovered over the keyboard without moving.

Truly and honestly, I do not get this seeming hatred being directed toward President-elect Obama. I hear it time and again on the news wire, and now I find it among my own social circle. In Kentucky, two men hung Obama in effigy, dangling from a tree with a noose around its neck, recalling the historical images of blacks being lynched in the South. At George Fox University in Oregon, four students were punished for hanging a likeness of Obama from a tree. In Redondo Beach, California., a woman hung Obama in effigy from her balcony with a knife in its neck. In Tennessee two white supremacists were arrested for planning the assassination of Obama. In Clarksville, Indiana, a man had hung Obama in effigy from a tree. In Rexburg, Idaho, a number of elementary school students were chanting on the school bus, "Assassinate Obama! Assassinate Obama!" Also in Idaho, the Bonner Country sheriff and a Secret Service agent will be investigating a man who put up a sign in his yard that said "Free Public Hanging" with a noose hanging in front of it and the name "Obama" just below it.

It is even in my limited social circle. "Disgusting," the comment pointedly stated. I do not understand it.

November 11, 2008

'Illogical' Doctrine? Prove It.

In a message board conversation I observed someone saying:

The idea of God, having a Son, who is born by a virgin, never sins, never makes a mistake while walking the earth, is crucified, resurrected in three days, and the result of this transpiration of events was the forgiveness of everyone's sins, with the possibility of eternal life with God, is fantastically illogical . . . and this is what makes it great! There is nothing logical in those remarks above. If you contend they are logical, then by all means, make the argument those events are "logical"

"Illogical," he said. An interesting charge, and one that we should not give a pass to. So here is the question that I want to deal with: "What should be the Christian's response to this?" It is a common enough attack, given the typical rhetoric dispensed by atheists, particularly those advocating the 'new atheism' advanced by the likes of Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens, et al.

I think the Christian's response should pay careful consideration to that word being used: "illogical." The response ought not ignore that word. If an atheist wants to claim that these beliefs are illogical, then he should be held accountable for that claim; he needs to present an argument that makes his case. One of two things would happen. The easiest option would be for him to notice how indefensible such an argument is and choose to employ a different, more defensible attack. Obviously that will invoke a different argument, which means this one was wisely abandoned and we can ignore it, focusing our analysis on whatever new attack he proposes.

The other option, of course, is that he will stick to his claim. And it is preferable that he does, I think, because it is the weakest argument he could raise, the easiest one to take apart. I enjoy disemboweling bad arguments, mostly because I enjoy making a spectacle of what 'bad arguments' are. So if he sticks to this attack then the first thing the Christian should do is point out that what we have here is a claim, not an argument. The atheist here has stated his case. Now he must make his case, such as reason obliges him to do. (We are assuming the atheist esteems reason, which they typically profess to do.)

You can see in this anecdotal example that he has tried to shift the burden of proof onto the Christian: "If you contend they are logical," he said, "[then] make the argument [that] those events are logical." He cannot be permitted to get away with this shifting of the burden. Such a tactic is an affront to reason, for by implication it commits the argumentum ad ignorantiam fallacy. What he is essentially saying is, "My case is true unless you can prove it false." And there is nothing intellectually appealing or compelling about fallacious arguments. This is key: If he thinks there is any truth to his claim, then he needs to establish its truth. He must present his ratio veritatis. He cannot simply assume its truth, thinking that it carries weight by the mere force of his assertion (and it is therefore up to the Christian to prove it false). In the arena of critical thinking, that is called an ipse dixit, a Latin term to describe the fallacious sophistry of an unsupported assertion being presented as true by fiat.

Moreover I contend that Christians do not shoulder the burden because there is nothing obviously illogical about those beliefs. For example, there is nothing obviously illogical (i.e., contrary to logic) about a son being born of a virgin. In fact, parthenogenesis has been observed to occur naturally in a variety of species of certain plants, invertebrates, and vertebrates. And given our current understanding about mammalian reproduction, it may seem contrary to science that a virgin could give birth to a child but there is nothing contrary to logic about it. There is a very important difference between science (a posteriori knowledge) and logic (a priori knowledge); they are categorically different, such that when something is contrary to science it does not necessarily follow that it is contrary to logic.

(I would also note that prior to the dawn of the 21st century it was thought that parthenogenesis in mammals was impossible, on account of their imprinted genetic regions. But due to the work of South Korean scientist Hwang Woo-Suk in early 2004 and the Tokyo University of Agriculture shortly thereafter, plus the efforts of the International Stem Cell Corporation from 2007, etc., the creation of human parthenogenetic stem cell lines from unfertilized eggs has been achieved with tremendous success. Just imagine what we will 'know' ten years from now.)

How about the idea that Jesus never sinned? Again, there is nothing obviously illogical about it. (It is debatable whether or not Jesus "never [made] a mistake while walking the earth" because there was a definite religious status quo that he contravened almost routinely; but such does not determine 'sin'.) Something is 'illogical' when it runs contrary to logic qua logic. How exactly does a 'sinless life' run contrary to logic? What principle of logic does it violate? It is certainly not obvious; ergo, it must be shown to be illogical, and this test applies to the entirety of his above claim. Although I think he could make an argument for how certain doctrines run contrary to our common human experience, an entirely different argument is called for when claiming that they violate the laws of logic. Furthermore, to cite a doctrine (e.g., Christ's resurrection) as contradicting our human experience forcefully demonstrates its status as 'miraculous' but it pointedly fails to demonstrate it as 'illogical' because logic is a priori knowledge; it is neither defined by human experience nor a product of scientific inquiry (a posteriori knowledge). On the question of whether something is 'illogical' or not, human experience and science are irrelevant.

So the atheist here, having stated his case, must now make his case. This, reason obliges him to do. And if he wants to stick with his claim about these beliefs being "illogical," his burden is heavy indeed. I would look enthusiastically forward to such attempts because I cannot imagine how one would go about meeting that burden. It would be exciting to observe—or, more probably, anti-climatic.